Agile vs. Scrum Project Management Frameworks

Written by
Alexander Jiménez

A project's success depends a lot on its management framework. Yet, it can be challenging to decide which one suits you best. This article will help you understand two of the most popular frameworks. Next time you run any project, you'll know which one is better for you. Read on!

What is the General Definition of a Project?

Before getting started, let's talk about what a project is. In this context, a project is a set of activities to achieve a specific goal. These involve tasks, resources, and stakeholders and often have a beginning and end date. Typically, the project manager handles planning, organizing, and controlling project activities. They also consist of monitoring progress and making adjustments as the project progresses. 

What is a Project Management Framework?

A PM framework is a set of guidelines that ensures the project's completion. It sets up objectives and assigns roles and responsibilities to each team member. It can also help you to stay organized with timelines and deliverables. This system lets you track progress throughout the product's life cycle. Here, frameworks include Scrum, Agile, Waterfall, and Kanban. Further, there's also Project Management Body of Knowledge (PMBOK) and Extreme Programming (XP). Let's look at some of the most popular PM frameworks!

Agile vs. Scrum Project Management

What is Agile Methodology?

Agile Management emphasizes on rapid delivery of high-quality products with minimal overhead. It seeks collaboration, iterative development, continuous improvement, and frequent stakeholder feedback. By following agile principles, teams ensure meeting project requirements while solid a strong customer level of trust. 

How does Agile work?

Agile Methodology breaks a project into shorter development cycles and works each piece. As a result, it can measure progress using velocity, cycle time, team load, and success rate metrics. Agile ensures stakeholders' collaboration and the entire team goes in the same direction. The result of this collaboration is cutting-edge products!

It also promotes continuous improvement through regular feedback loops. So that your team can address issues as they develop. This way, you'll avoid significant roadblocks during the development process.

Pros and Cons of Agile

Agile principles are widespread across many industries. However, the number of software development projects that use it grows daily. It can offer you many advantages over traditional project management frameworks.

High levels of adaptability to react to user requirements.
● Collaboration among members during the entire project.
● Frequent feedback within the team.
● High-quality product delivery.
● Its iterative approach helps teams identify problems.
● More agile and responsive when addressing user needs.

On the other hand, there are some cons to this methodology.

● Agile's kind of unflexible structure can make changes challenging to implement.
● It often results in many meetings, which can be time-consuming and annoying.
● It can be challenging to maintain over long periods due to its demanding nature.
● Due to the prior, it can lead to burnout and decreased motivation.

The Agile project methodology is robust for delivering software products quickly and reliably. You can take advantage of its full potential if you understand its principles. With Agile frameworks, you can ensure you complete your projects on time and within budget. 

Agile vs. Other Frameworks

The Agile Framework offers many advantages. Nonetheless, PMs must identify when to use it compared to other frameworks. 

Agile vs. Kanban

Agile and Kanban are popular Project Management frameworks widely used in the software industry. Agile is iterative, while Kanban is a visual system for managing workflows. Agile teams emphasize collaboration, self-organization, and continuous improvement. They work in sprints, setting goals for each iteration. On the other hand, Kanban uses boards to track progress and identify bottlenecks. It also provides transparency, allowing everyone to understand critical milestones and deadlines. 

Agile vs. Waterfall

The Agile approach focuses on sprints to develop new features based on the environment or user needs. By iterating through different stages, it assesses to make changes without wasting resources. Otherwise, Waterfall is more traditional and follows a linear process. Sometimes, it can result in delays or costly rework if an issue arises mid-project.

When choosing one, you must consider scope, timeline, and budget. Agile may be better suited for smaller projects with limited resources. Waterfall may be better for larger-scale projects with more rigid timelines and budgets.

Agile vs. Scrum Project Management

What is Scrum Methodology?

Scrum is a PM framework that seeks to deliver complex projects faster and better. It's a lightweight process in iterations that result in a finished product. It includes three roles: scrum master, product owner, and development team. Each position has specific responsibilities and works together towards completing the project successfully. 

1.  The scrum master ensures that all team members follow the processes.
2.  The product owner handles setting the strategic vision for the project.
3.  The development team executes the tasks to complete the project according to deadlines. 

How does Scrum work?

Scrum is a PM framework initially developed by Ken Schwaber and Jeff Sutherland. It provides a lightweight process for teams to work together in short iterations. Through scrum, teams can become more effective, productive, and innovative. Scrum projects come in all sizes and shapes due to their flexibility and scalability. Whether you're a startup with limited resources or a large enterprise, you can use it. By leveraging scrum's systematic approach, businesses can achieve better results while maintaining efficiency. 

Pros and Cons of Scrum

Scrum focuses on incremental delivery, flexibility, and transparency within the project environment. As such, it has many advantages for you that want to maximize efficiency and success. Here are some of the benefits of using this approach.

● It focuses on short rather than long-term sprint goals to make teams more productive.
● It helps keep everyone motivated while completing tasks with shorter deadlines.
● Scrum encourages open communication throughout the whole process.
● Teams work on collaboration as one unit towards a common goal.

As with everything, Scrum has some drawbacks as well.

● Each sprint has a well-defined timeline that can be challenging to keep up. 
● Teams must be well organized and disciplined enough to avoid missing deadlines.
● Its bases are on self-organizing teams with different-background people collaborating.
● Teams need to deliver a certain amount of work within each sprint. 
● The workflow may be overwhelming if the workload isn't manageable. 
● Scrum involves taking risks that could lead to failure if not adequately managed. 

Scrum vs. Other Frameworks

The Scrum framework offers a more effective alternative to traditional methods. It focuses on collaboration, flexibility, and adaptability to changing conditions. With scrum, you'll have the tools to stay ahead of your competition.

Scrum vs. Kanban

Scrum focuses on delivering value through short cycles. It's great for teams who need structure and guidance when tackling complex projects. On the other hand, Kanban helps team enhancement by limiting its work-in-progress. It's ideal for groups that look for more flexibility and control over their process. 

Scrum vs. Waterfall

Scrum framework is an excellent choice for agile projects that require frequent changes. Yet, it is challenging to manage complex projects with it. Likewise, Waterfall is better suited for large-scale projects with precise requirements. It's not as flexible for mid-project changes. 

Agile vs. Scrum: When to Choose Each Framework?

Agile and Scrum are both powerful PM frameworks. In certain situations, one framework may be better than the other. When deciding between both, it's essential to consider your project's goals. For projects that need flexibility, Agile is generally the better choice. It allows teams to adapt quickly to changing requirements. With it, you can respond rapidly to user feedback or new market conditions.

On the other hand, when you need high-level precision or long-term planning, Scrum is the one to choose. It provides more structure for longer-term planning than Agile values. It also encourages collaboration among team members through daily meetings known as "scrums." In addition, it's also important to consider how much control you need over processes. With Agile, you can have more autonomy when adapting your plans and methods. However, Scrum has stricter rules about how to do things. There's usually a higher level of oversight from product owners.

Final Thoughts

There are many Project Management Approaches out there! Choosing one that suits your needs and core values is critical. We hope to have helped you to know more about how each work to ensure successful projects!

Our human-centered approach and hard-earned reputation make us able to deliver successful, top-notch, and stunning products. Whether you're looking to move from an idea into a business or thinking of new iterations for your product, our UX-focused Custom Software Development company is here to help. Feel free to reach out, and let's shape the future together!
Contact us!